Comparison

Rewardful vs Tolt

FirstPromoter is a better choice than Rewardful and Tolt for SaaS companies that want a complete, fully customizable affiliate platform with advanced control and built-in tools. Rewardful offers a simple setup for Stripe-based programs, and Tolt delivers clean UX for early-stage teams, but both fall short on flexible commissions, advanced reporting, and dashboard customization.

Rewardful vs Tolt

Why SaaS companies choose FirstPromoter

Discover the top three reasons why SaaS companies choose FirstPromoter over the competition.

14-day free trial. No credit card required.

Flexible commissions

Reward affiliates the way your business actually works. Use multi-tier, multi-level, and per-product rewards, or set different commissions across plans and price IDs to match how you sell.

Advanced reporting

18 data points covering clicks, conversions, revenue, and affiliate behavior. Slice the numbers the way you need them and uncover patterns most basic dashboards miss.

Brandable affiliate dashboard

Take the dashboard well beyond a logo swap. Use a custom domain, set your typography and colors, and inject CSS or JS to make the experience indistinguishable from the rest of your product.

Feature FirstPromoter Tolt Rewardful
Best for SaaS companies that want fast setup and scalable affiliate control Early-stage SaaS looking for simple, modern setup Early-stage SaaS needing quick setup
Core differentiator Flexible, developer-friendly affiliate software with full control Clean UX, modern UI, simple setup Simple setup for recurring Stripe-based affiliate programs
Billing integrations Stripe, Paddle, Chargebee, Braintree, Recurly Stripe, Paddle, Chargebee Stripe, Paddle
Link tracking capabilities Advanced tracking with links, postbacks, and attribution control Link tracking with basic attribution Basic referral link tracking
Coupon capabilities Coupon tracking, auto-create Stripe coupons, multiple coupons per affiliate Coupon tracking (no auto-generation) Coupon tracking with Stripe sync
Attribution options Flexible attribution (links, coupons, direct tracking) Standard attribution Primarily Stripe-based attribution (first/last touch)
Commission flexibility One-time, recurring, multi-tier, multi-level, custom rewards per plan/product One-time, recurring, custom rewards (no multi-tier or multi-level) One-time and recurring commissions with limited customization
Payouts PayPal & Wise bulk payouts, auto-managed payouts, EU invoicing Bulk payouts supported, no built-in auto-managed payouts or invoicing PayPal & Wise payouts, managed payouts (beta with fee)
Reporting Advanced reporting with 18 data points and detailed breakdowns Limited reporting Basic reporting with limited depth
Fraud controls Advanced fraud detection, approval rules, refund tracking Basic fraud protection + refund tracking Basic fraud detection and refund handling
Affiliate dashboard branding Fully customizable, custom domain, CSS/JS support Limited branding (custom domain only) Basic branding with limited customization
Email automation Built-in email automation + broadcast emails Email automation + broadcasts Limited email functionality
Tax form collection Built-in W-9 / W-8BEN collection Not included Not included
Team members & roles Unlimited team members with custom roles and permissions No role separation (same permissions for all users) Not supported
Postbacks & API Postbacks, API, and webhooks for flexible integrations API available Limited API capabilities, no postbacks
Starting price $49 / $99 / $149+ per month $69 / $99 / $199+ per month $49 / $99 / $149+ per month

Worry free migration

Worried about migration? Leave it to us. We can help you migrate your promoters to FirstPromoter if you are using another platform.

  • Affiliates don't have to change the links
  • Reliable migration assistance
  • Simple and standard migration process
Migrating affiliates to FirstPromoter

3 simple steps

Frame 152060

Choose the right plan for you

comparison steps arrow down
Frame 152060 1

Share the CSV file with the affiliate & referral details

comparison steps arrow up
Frame 152060 2

Migration will be completed in 24-48 hours

We’ve been using FirstPromoter for over 5 years. It has helped us bring in hundreds of thousands of dollars of additional revenue, while being managed by just a single person.

John O'Nolan
John O’Nolan
Founder & CEO at Ghost.org

Why customers choose us

Your business is in good hands

Our dedicated Customer Success team is there for you when you need it most.

FirstPromoter has been great, been loving the new update – much more cleaner and the new way of coupon codes is a game changer. Tracking is great and shows all numbers that needs to be seen!
David Zitoun, Submagic
David Zitoun Co-founder at Submagic
Customer service has been excellent, and the platform itself is very sleek and intuitive. For a growing affiliate program, it’s perfect!
Ethan Housen, CustomGPT
Ethan Housen Marketing and Partnership Manager at CustomGPT
It’s gotten a lot easier since the launch of V2 for sure! Honestly, our work with FirstPromoter currently is very low since we have everything set up: new affiliates get onboarded automatically and we offer to have a call with them. Rest of the work is: go through new applications once a week, check out data at least once a month, send out emails to affiliates if we do campaigns/have product releases.
Julia Schlocker, neuroflash
Julia Schlocker Product Ops Managerin at neuroflash

Common questions

These are the questions we hear most often.

No, it’s not. FirstPromoter works for any subscription or recurring-revenue business. Try it for free and see how it works for YOUR business!

Don’t see the answer you need?

That’s ok. Just drop a message and we will get back to you ASAP.

Go live before the end of the day

Connect billing, set commission rules and launch. Tracking, payouts and compliance scale from day one.

14-day free trial. No credit card required.